If you have kids and you celebrate Christmas, you’re probably familiar with the Elf on the Shelf — a storybook and accompanying doll that help encourage your little darlings to behave themselves before the holidays. The book tells wide-eyed children how Santa marshals an army of scout elves to sneak into their houses before Christmas, then fly back to the North Pole every night to rat out the stinkers. Every day the elves return find a new place to hide, which turns this whole monstrous Fourth Amendment violation into an adorable ongoing game of hide and seek.
Parents love how the elf enforces good behavior. (Mommy says it’s that or an extra glass of wine!) But not everyone is a fan. The Atlantic magazine mocks it as a “marketing juggernaut dressed up as a tradition” that bullies kids into thinking good behavior equals presents. The Washington Post condemns it as “just another nannycam in a nanny state obsessed with penal codes.” And a Canadian professor argues that the elf brainwashes kids into accepting the surveillance state: “if you grow up thinking it’s cool for the elves to watch me and report back to Santa, well, then it’s cool for the NSA to watch me and report back to the government.”
Our friends at the IRS have their own version of the Elf on the Shelf. In fact, they have several — and they’re all more effective than the pointy-hatted little informant spying on your kids. Here’s how the IRS knows if you’ve been naughty when it comes to reporting your presents throughout the year:
- The first “elf” is the IRS’s computerized income matching program. For example, employers report wages on Form W2, mutual funds report investment income on Form 1099-DIV, and partnerships report partners’ income and expenses on Schedule K1. IRS computers cross-check these figures to your return to make sure you’ve reported those amount. If you haven’t, you’ll get a lump of coal notice calculating how much more you owe and a deadline for paying up.
- If computerized matching fails, the IRS can squeeze more information out of third parties. If the IRS elves suspect mischief, they can subpoena your bank records then add up your deposits to make sure you’ve reported the income. If those deposits add up to more than you’ve reported, the IRS will assume the difference is taxable. Good luck convincing a Tax Court judge that Santa left that extra cash in your stocking!
- Finally, the IRS dangles cash bounties to catch tax cheats. The IRS Whistleblower Office pays rewards of up to 30% of amounts it collects in disputes topping $2 million. Bradley Birkenfeld, who helped the IRS score an $852 million settlement with Swiss bank UBS, spent two years in jail for his part in the scheme, but walked away with a $104 million reward for his effort. We can think of an elf or two who would be happy to make that trade!The IRS systems may not be quite as effective as what the CIA or Department of Homeland Security can put to work. But they put that stool pigeon Elf to shame, at least until they can force Santa into filing a 1099-GIFT for every present he leaves.